Why you should make a gift instead of buying one?

Shopping for gifts is hard. Sometimes it seems like the better you know someone, the harder it is to decide what to get them. If you’re stuck, take some advice from psychology: People value an item more if they put it together themselves.

In 2012, behavioral economist Dan Ariely, along with Tulane marketing professor Daniel Mochon and Michael Norton of Harvard Business School, set out to study what they call the “IKEA effect”: that is, the idea that people value something more when they put it together themselves.

For the study, they recruited 52 college students and had half assemble a plain black IKEA storage box. The other half got a fully assembled box and were asked to inspect it. Next, the researchers asked the volunteers to make a bid on the box, telling them that if their bid was equal to or above a random price they pulled out of a hat, they could pay the bid and get the box. As you might expect, those who built the box were willing to spend more — 63 percent more, to be exact — than those who got the box fully assembled.

In another experiment, they gave volunteers high-quality origami paper and instructions on how to fold either a crane or a frog. Once they were done with their creations, they were asked to bid on them in the same way previous volunteers bid on their IKEA pieces. Next, the researchers showed the pieces — along with some masterful pieces created by experienced origami artists — to strangers. Sure enough, the volunteers were willing to pay nearly five times as much for their own creations as strangers were, and almost as much as strangers were willing to pay for the expert creations. “Thus,” the researchers write, “while the non-builders saw the amateurish creations as nearly worthless crumpled paper, our builders imbued their origami with value.” Harsh, guys.

Business owners have been aware of this tendency for a while. In response to a plateau in sales of cake mix in the 1950s, food manufacturers changed the recipe to require consumers to add an egg, thereby putting something of themselves into an overly simple task. Although the impact that had on cake-mix sales is questionable, the motivation holds up. You’ve probably heard of plenty of farms that let you pick your own pumpkin at Halloween and cut down your own tree at Christmas. From the hands-on customization of Build-a-Bear to the viral popularity of DIY frozen-yogurt shops, businesses know that people love the stuff they do themselves.

So gift givers, take note! But also be wary: There was one more phenomenon Ariely and his team noticed in their study. When people didn’t finish assembling their box, that extra value they placed in the item vanished. That means if your gift is too hard to put together, the idea may backfire. So go ahead, buy your sweetie a new desk or give your kid a build-your-own-robot kit. Just maybe don’t make grandma build a PC — unless your grandma is Shakuntala Devi.

Check out my related post: How did Hallmark come about?


Interesting reads:

https://byrnepelofsky.com/time-talent-and-treasure-part-three-of-a-three-part-series/

https://www.learningtogive.org/resources/gifts-time-talent-and-treasure

https://www.coupons.com/thegoodstuff/16-one-of-a-kind-gifts-theyll-treasure-forever/

https://qz.com/825331/the-real-reasons-we-give-gifts/

https://holidappy.com/gift-ideas/reasons-to-give-hand-made-gifts

https://curiosity.com/topics/to-give-a-gift-theyll-treasure-go-with-some-assembly-required-curiosity

http://serendipitymommy.com/7-unique-personalized-gifts-they-will-treasure-forever/

4 thoughts on “Why you should make a gift instead of buying one?

  1. Good read, it made me laugh toward the end too. thank you for that.
    When I was younger, I always thought that, hey, I can just go to Ikea and buy that product and DIY. Oh Boy, was I so wrong! All because of that one screw, or that funny looking piece which doesn’t look like any of the part on that instruction Manuel. And, you can imagine the rest.
    I realised then, dinners are always more worth-it. Or a hand-made card.
    making a gift instead of buying one, has a personal touch.
    However good read. 👏

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s